Opiniones

Comentarios de usuarios

Crítica de los usuarios - Marcar como inadecuado

that was wonderful and perfection

Crítica de los usuarios - Marcar como inadecuado

This review is accurate, in that the soloists were indeed "frequently rushed" by conductor Robert Shaw. He was determined to leave his own mark on the Mass in B Minor, with his "concertists" interpretation. There were five, not four, soloists; "concertists style" simply meant that Mr. Shaw designated specific passages in the choral movements to be sung not by the chorus but by the five soloists--actually five "concertists." My feeling was, in this particular performance at least, "concertists" style was not something the audience could appreciate or enjoy; it simply did not work. Possibly in a recording, this interpretation was more successful.
My fondest memories of performing with Robert Shaw are not as a soloists but in my Conservatory days, as a professional member of the St. Louis Symphony Chorus, when Mr. Shaw appeared as a guest conductor. I recall being part of a sublime small female vocal ensemble, performing "Lift Thine Eyes," from Mendelssohn's Elijah. Shaw spent over an hour hand-selecting us for this: three first sopranos, three second sopranos, and I was the only singer on the alto staff. We performed it from the balcony of Powell Symphony Hall, St. Louis, and as I recall the audience really loved it!
Gretchen Greenfield
http://gretchengreenfield.brandyourself.com/
 

Todos los comentarios - 2
5 estrellas - 0
4 estrellas - 0
3 estrellas - 0
2 estrellas - 0
1 estrella - 0

Todos los comentarios - 2
Comentarios editoriales - 0