Observations of the Lord Advocate-Mr Clerk-Lord Gil lies-Lord Advocate-Lord Justice Clerk-Lord Advocate-Lord Gillies-Lord Justice Clerk-Lord Advocate Minutes of the Debate Interlocutor III.-Minutes. 34 36 37 Minute of the search of practice Additional Minutes IV.-Proceedings on 26th May. The Judges present....... The Counsel for the Crown, and for the Pannel The Pannel cited...................................................... The Lord Justice Clerk asks the Judges to give their opi Lord Gillies' Observation Mr Drummond's Speech....... Lord Advocate's Observation.......... Mr Drummond in continuation.... 38 41 1 1 1 2 2 14 14 14 24 25 Opinions of the Judges. Lord Hermand...... Lord Gillies IL-PROCEEDINGS AGAINST ANDREW M'KINLEY. The Judges present I.-Proceedings on 2d June. PAGE. 1 1 1 2 The Counsel for the Crown, and for the Pannel Lord Advocate's Speech ...... Lord Justice Clerk's Observation......... The Indictment..................... The Pannel pleads not guilty................................ The Lord Justice Clerk asks, whether the Counsel for the Mr Cranstoun's Speech Lord Justice Clerk's Observation...... Mr Grant's Speech Mr Clerk's Speech Mr Drummond's Speech Lord Advocate's Observation ...................... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... Mr Clerk's Speech.............. Opinions of the Judges................ Interlocutor 29 9 9 37 38 58 60 75 75 94 96 H.-Proceedings on 23d June. The Judges present .... The Counsel for the Crown, and for the Pannel The Indictment .... Pannel pleads not guilty ...... Discussion between the Counsel for the Crown and the Counsel for the Pannel, as to the time when the Informations for the Pannel should be ordered to be given into Court, and Opinions of the Judges............... Interlocutor ...... III.-Informations. Information for the Prosecutor........ Information for the Pannel............... Supplementary Information for the Pannel IV.-Proceedings on 18th July. The Judges present ..... The Counsel for the Crown, and for the Pannel................. 1 25 81 1 1 Lord Justice Clerk asks the Opinions of the Judges on the Mr Clerk wishes to state something in addition to what is Lord Hermand's Opinion......... Lord Pitmilly Lord Reston ... Lord Justice Clerk PAGE. Observations of the Lord Advocate-Mr Grant-Lord 71 V-Proceedings on 19th July. The Counsel for the Crown, and for the Pannel Lord Advocate's Speech.. Mr Cranstoun's Speech Mr Grant's Speech...... Lord Advocate's Observation............................................................................................................................. Lord Justice Clerk's Observation........ Minute, restricting the Libel to an arbitary punishment Other Preliminary Proceedings and Observations of the Discussion whether Mr Salmond should be allowed to re- Minute admitting the Declarations of the Panne................ Mr Jeffrey objects to the Witness, John Campbell-Dis- John Campbell sworn-His Deposition, in initialibus- Peter Gibson James Finlayson Lord Justice Clerk's Observation to the Jury Lord Justice Clerk's Address to Andrew M'Kinley. Andrew M'Kinley's Speech PAGE. 86 86 87 87 APPENDIX. No. I.-Proceedings against James M'Ewan, and others, at II. Containing sundry Letters of John Campbell........ 1 6 DIRECTIONS TO THE BINDER. After the title-page, notice, and index, the proceedings in the trials of Edgar and M'Kinley are to be placed in the following order : : |