Containing cases decided from February 16, 1912, to April 23, 1912. LEL FRANKFORT, KY.: FRANKFORT PRINTING CO., PRINTERS AND BINDERS 1912 JUDICIAL OFFICERS OF THE STATE COURT OF APPEALS OF KENTUCKY (As constituted during the period covered by this volume from February 16, 1912, to April 23, 1912.) Hon. J. P. HOBSON, Chief Justice. ASSOCIATE JUSTICES Hon. JOHN D. CARROLL Hon. JOHN M. LASSING Hon. T. J. NUNN Hon. W. E. SETTLE Hon. SHACKELFORD MILLER Hon. ROBERT H. WINN Hon. WM. ROGERS CLAY, Commissioner. OFFICERS OF THE COURT JAMES GARNETT, Attorney General. JAMES D. BLACK, First Assistant Attorney General. M. M. LOGAN, Second Assistant Attorney General. CHARLES H. MORRIS, Third Assistant Attorney General. T. R. MCBEATH, Reporter Court of Appeals. ROBT. L. GREENE, Clerk Court of Appeals. i JUDGES OF CIRCUIT COURTS Elected November, 1909. 1st District-R. G. BUGG 2nd District-W. M. REED, 3rd District-J. T. HANBERRY 4th District-J. F. GORDON 5th District-J. W. HENSON 6th District-T. F. BIRKHEAD 7th District-W. P. SANDIDGE 8th District - MCKENZIE MOSS 9th District-WEED S. CHELF 10th District-SAMUEL E. JONES 11th District-I. H. THURMAN 12th District-CHARLES MARSHALL 13th District-*CHARLES A. HARDIN 14th District-R. L. STOUT ... 15th District-J. W. CAMMACK 16th District-F. M. TRACY 16th District-M. L. HARBESON 17th District-CHARLES Y. YUNGBLUT 18th District-L. P. FRYER 19th District-C. D. NEWELL 20th District-W. C. HALBERT 21st District-ALLIE W. YOUNG 22nd District * CHAS. KERR 23rd District-D. B. REDWINE 24th District-A. J. KIRK 25th District-J. M. BENTON 26th District-*W. T. DAVIS 27th District-WILLIAM LEWIS 28th District-B. J. BETHURUM 29th District-J. C. CARTER 30th District-Jefferson Circuit Court-Louisville JAMES P. GREGORY-Criminal Branch. Harrodsburg Versailles Owenton .Covington Newport Falmouth Maysville Vanceburg Mt. Sterling Lexington Jackson Pikeville Winchester Pineville London ..Somerset Tompkinsville *†JAMES QUARLES-Chancery Branch, First Division. 31st District-D. W. GARDNER 32nd District-J. B. HANNAH 33rd District-L. D. LEWIS 34th District-*FLEM D. SAMPSON *Elected November, 1911, to fill unexpired term. ...Salyersville Sandy Hook Hayden Williamsburg †R. W. BINGHAM from Jan. 10, 1911 to Nov. 24, 1911. COMMONWEALTH ATTORNEYS Elected November, 1909. 1st District-R. F. SMITH 2nd District-JOHN G. LOVETT 3rd District-DENNY P. SMITH 4th District-JOHN L. GRAYOT 5th District-S. V. DIXON 6th District-BEN D. RINGO 12th District-CHAS. H. SANFORD 27th District-J. C. CLOYD 28th District-M. L. JARVIS 29th District-A. A. HUDDLESTON 30th District-JOSEPH HUFFAKER 31st District-W. H. MAY 32nd District-J. W. WAUGH 33rd District-IRA FIELDS 34th District-*JOSEPH B. SNYDER *Elected November, 1911, to fill unexpired term. Clinton . L'enton Cadiz .Smithland Henderson Owensboro Elkton Scottsville Elizabethtown Bardstown Lebanon . New Castle Stanford Frankfort Warsaw Covington Newport Cynthiana .Augusta Grayson Mt. Sterling . Tallega Pikeville Nicholasville Harlan Manchester Somerset Burksville Louisville Prestonburg Grayson Whitesburg Willliamsburg |